Key takeaways
On Nov 6, 2026, Senior U.S. District Judge Joseph F. Bataillon of the District of Nebraska granted summary judgment to Credit Bureau Services, Inc. and C.J. Tighe in Stalnaker v. Credit Bureau Services, finding the plaintiffs "lack Article III standing" and dismissing the case.
The suit alleged FDCPA and Nebraska Consumer Protection Act violations in letters that sought interest on medical debts the court says "totaled less than $300."
The court relied on the Eighth Circuit's 2023 ruling in Bassett v. Credit Bureau Services, which involved the same defendants and held that a consumer who "only received the letter and never paid any part of the interest or principal" had not shown a concrete injury.
The court found no evidence to support the claimed financial, emotional or "informational" injuries, and no evidence tying them to the letters. It did not decide whether the letters broke either law.
Matt Lippl, Chief Product Officer, PayPath | Reviewed by Matt Lippl
Last reviewed: November 19, 2026
The short version. A federal judge in Nebraska ended a class action that challenged collection letters adding interest to small medical debts. The court did not rule on whether the letters were lawful. It held that the plaintiffs had not shown, with evidence, that the letters caused the consumer any concrete harm, which federal courts require before they can hear a case.
Who this applies to
This post is for collection agencies, debt buyers, collection law firms, healthcare billing teams and the compliance and legal staff who follow FDCPA litigation. It reports what two court opinions say. It doesn't say how either applies to any other case or business.
The case
The opinion lays out the background. Donna J. Lunsford (formerly Hamilton) filed a Chapter 7 bankruptcy petition on Sept 24, 2019, stating she had no claims against third parties; her debts were discharged and the case closed on Jan 21, 2020. She sued on April 13, 2020, bringing FDCPA and Nebraska Consumer Protection Act claims "based on a series of letters Defendants sent her," on behalf of herself and a putative class. Her bankruptcy was later reopened, a trustee took over the claim, and the bankruptcy court approved a split of any recovery, "75% to the estate and 25% to Lunsford." The trustee, now John Stalnaker, was substituted as plaintiff.
The case was then stayed while the Eighth Circuit decided Bassett, a separate case against the same collection agency. Afterward the plaintiffs amended their complaint to add an "informational injury" and other claimed harms, and to clarify that the letters sought interest as well as the medical debt.
What the Eighth Circuit said in Bassett
In Bassett v. Credit Bureau Services, Inc., 60 F.4th 1132 (8th Cir. 2023), the collectors sent a letter for medical bills that "listed amounts owed without distinguishing interest from principal" and said, "Interest and other charges may accrue daily." The district court had entered judgment for the consumer and the class. The Eighth Circuit vacated it, writing that Bassett "only received the letter and never paid any part of the interest or principal," and: "Bassett received a letter." Without a concrete injury in fact, the court wrote, Bassett was "not seeking to remedy any harm to herself but instead is merely seeking to ensure a defendant's compliance with regulatory law."
What the Nebraska court decided
Judge Bataillon, quoting an Eighth Circuit case, described standing as "a threshold inquiry into federal court jurisdiction" and limited the analysis to it. He took each claimed injury in turn:
Letters and interest. The court wrote that "it is undisputed that Lunsford, or anyone on her behalf, never paid any money to CBS," and the Eighth Circuit "specifically rejected" the letters-and-interest argument in Bassett.
Credit reporting. The plaintiffs "brought forth no evidence to support that CBS did indeed report her accounts to the credit bureaus."
Bankruptcy and costs. "Debts are the basis for bankruptcy, not letters about debts."
Copays. The only support was interrogatory answers, with no documents, no amounts and "no medical evidence linking the alleged copayments to the Letters."
Emotional distress. Citing Eighth Circuit cases that "confusion," "worry" and "sleeplessness" are not concrete injuries, the court wrote that the complaint "substitutes some words, but the 'negative emotions' they describe are basically the same."
Informational injury. The court wrote that the Eighth Circuit in Hekel "held that the plaintiff still must identify some 'downstream consequence'" from not receiving required information, and found none supported by evidence.
The court added that even with an injury, the plaintiffs had no evidence it was "caused by the defendant," pointing to undisputed evidence of a divorce, other debts and letters from many creditors. "The bankruptcy was caused by Lunsford filing," the court wrote.
The order denied the plaintiffs' motions for partial summary judgment and class certification, cancelled the trial setting, and said a separate judgment would be entered. As of Nov 19, 2026, the sources checked for this post do not report an appeal.
The open question
The ruling turned on the record of what happened to one consumer after the letters, not on what the letters said. The Eighth Circuit in Bassett also noted, in a footnote, that "Infliction of emotional distress and intrusion upon seclusion may be close common-law analogues" that Bassett had not raised. That leaves an open question for collection teams that follow these cases: in later FDCPA letter suits in the Eighth Circuit, what kind of evidence of harm will courts treat as enough?
For background on medical debt collection and credit reporting, see our Medical Debt glossary entry.
Related terms
Questions, answered
What did the court decide in Stalnaker v. Credit Bureau Services?
On Nov 6, 2026, the District of Nebraska granted the defendants' motion for summary judgment "in that the Court must dismiss for lack of Article III standing," and denied the plaintiffs' motions for partial summary judgment and class certification.
Did the court decide whether adding interest to the medical debts was legal?
No. The court said its analysis began and ended with standing.
What is Article III standing?
The opinion, quoting the Supreme Court in Spokeo v. Robins, lists three elements: that plaintiffs "(1) suffered an injury in fact, (2) that is fairly traceable to the challenged conduct of the defendant, and (3) that is likely to be redressed by a favorable judicial decision."
How does Bassett relate to this case?
Bassett was an earlier Eighth Circuit case against the same collection agency. The Nebraska court cited it for the point that sending letters and adding interest, "without more," is not an injury in fact.
Sources & further reading
For general information only, not legal advice. Sources are linked above. Teams often review their programs with their own compliance team or counsel.
By Matt Lippl, Chief Product Officer, PayPath | Reviewed by Matt Lippl | Last reviewed November 19, 2026